Filopedia Español
Portrait of Hui Shi
Image: Wikimedia Commons

Hui Shi

369 BC–309 BC · Chinese philosopher of the School of Names and minister of the state of Wei

Share:FacebookWhatsApp

Hui Shi (c. 370–310 BCE), also known as Huizi or "Master Hui", was a Chinese philosopher of the Warring States period and a representative of the School of Names, also called the Logicians (mingjia). He is best remembered for his paradoxes about time, space, and the relation between concepts such as sameness and difference.

He served King Hui of Wei as a minister and, according to some sources, as chancellor. He is also credited with drafting a penal code that the king thought was good, though it could not be put into practice. None of his writings survive. We know his ideas mainly through other texts, above all the Zhuangzi, which portrays him as a close acquaintance, a skilled debater, and a man who valued peace. That work also records his ten theses, whose interpretation is still disputed. Some scholars suspect he meant to support Mozi's doctrine of mutual love.

Hui Shi often relied on analogies and paradoxical arguments, and claims such as that heaven and earth are equally high puzzled his contemporaries. His influence can be seen in later Chinese logical debate, though the lack of direct sources limits any firm assessment of his work.

Key ideas

  • Relativity of big and small: the greatest has nothing beyond it and the smallest has nothing within it, so magnitudes depend on how they are considered.
  • Paradoxes of time and space: he claimed to have set off for Yue today and arrived yesterday, questioning the idea of fixed time and distance.
  • Sameness and difference: every thing is both similar to and different from others, depending on the criterion used.
  • Universal love: he adopted Mozi's ideal of mutual love and linked it to the unity of heaven, earth, and all things.

Curiosities

Rescued from the river

According to the Zhuangzi, Hui Shi fell into the water while hurrying to cross a river to take up the post of prime minister of Liang. A boatman rescued him and pointed out that without him Hui Shi could not have held that office.

An unworkable code

The king of Wei approved Hui Shi's penal code, and the people accepted it, yet it proved impractical. A third party explained to the king that governing requires cooperation, much like carrying a heavy beam requires several people.

Original Filopedia text based on Wikipedia (es) and Wikipedia (en) and Wikidata.